How the new MEC logo should have been done

Mountain Equipment Co-op is taking a lot of heat from members over its new logo. They could have avoided this rather easily.

First, some background. MEC is a Vancouver-born co-op that sells outdoor clothing and gear. They’ve been around since 1971. Canada-wide membership is about 3.5 million. In Vancouver, where fleece and Gore-Tex come in pretty handy, you don’t run into many people who aren’t members.

MEC logo old and new
Mountain Equipment Co-op, the old (left) and the new.

Last week, MEC used its Facebook page to introduce its first logo change in 39 years, switching from the one on the left to the one on the right.

The Facebook post announcing the change was peppered with critical comments, as was a follow-up post responding to the outcry. MEC’s lead designer then explained the changes in a blog post that didn’t fare much better. (Sympathy to MEC’s community managers, who gamely tried to engage and keep up with the onslaught.)

Members didn’t like that the iconic mountain was gone. They thought three letters in a square looked a lot like a GAP logo. (Coincidentally, I happened to attend an event by Scandinavian outfit Hyper Island on the same day MEC’s new logo was released, and their logo, below left, looks even more similar.)

Hyper Island logo
Hyper Island’s logo.

So I can’t argue with the criticism that MEC’s designers (Concrete of Toronto) didn’t exactly break new ground.

But for MEC members, it was also personal. They felt they hadn’t had any say, and that a co-op is no place for decisions as fundamental as this one to come from the top down.

With the kind of outreach the internet now allows, there’s really no excuse for leaving constituents feeling unconsulted like this.

A simple logo-design competition, open to and adjudicated by MEC members, could have kept everyone happy.

I suspect hundreds of talented creatives in the Vancouver area alone have MEC memberships. They might have been interested in a first prize of, say, $5,000 in MEC merchandise. Waterproof bike panniers for the MacBook, that sort of thing.

Shortlisted entries could have been hosted on a password-protected website for members to provide their input. Members could grade them all on a scale of 1 to 10, rank their top five, or whatever.

At the end of it, MEC could choose the winner, grant the prize, blog about it on their website and thank members for helping with the decision. They’d have a great logo designed by an MEC member. They’d have saved tens of thousands of dollars. The membership would feel like it had a say. Everybody wins.

Instead, they have generic logo and a membership that feels alienated.

Update (June 25): I got some feedback on this post that I’d like to include. The first comes in this tweet from Lisa Corcoran:

I agree with Lisa’s point, and perhaps should have gone into a little more detail about how I see this competition running. To me, branding by committee is when a lot of different people contribute to the same logo, it gets tweaked dozens if not hundreds of times, and you end up with a logo that nobody likes but everybody can live with. As Lisa says, that’s not likely to be innovative, and it’s not what I had in mind. I imagined every entry in this competition representing the work and vision of a single artist. There would be a lot of them to choose from, but each would be its own strong statement and none of them would be watered down by committee.

As for the voting, I’m not suggesting it be “most votes wins.” Crowds have been known to make uninspiring choices when given the final say. I’m just saying the people in charge at MEC should be guided by members’ feedback in their deliberations. It’s a safeguard against choosing something that everybody will dislike. The emblems that prove most popular should get serious consideration.

Now, on to the fun stuff. MEC member Sean Perrin got in touch to show me a few logos he created. They retain the beloved mountain, but otherwise aren’t far from what MEC’s designers came up with:

I think those would look pretty good on backpacks. I bet the members would like them, too.

 

 

Is it just me, or is there some Gangnam Style in Richmond?

After watching the “Gangnam Style” video, my kids asked me what Gangnam was. So I decided to take them on a little Google Street View tour. I just plunked the cursor down on a random street in the Gangnam district of Seoul, and I got a surprise when we got to street level — the […]

Student interview: Social media and the Vancouver Stanley Cup riot

Every once in a while I receive an interview request from a journalism student who wants my views on some aspect of digital journalism. Last week Adam Kveton of Carleton University was interested in how social media affected the Vancouver Stanley Cup riot and The Province‘s coverage of it. Here’s our e-mail interview: Did journalists […]

Links I liked this week, Vol. 7

Every weekend I round up a few links that caught my interest as they drifted past during the previous week. Many are related to digital journalism and writing, but they may also touch on my other interests like sports, music or life in Vancouver. Here’s the seventh installment: A huge decision came down from the […]

Links I liked this week, Vol. 6

Occupy Wall Street gives birth to Occupy Vancouver this week, which may explain the political bent in this, the sixth installment of links I liked this week: I just discovered Peter Lewis, who explained in a post earlier this week that the outgoing CEO of the Gannett newspaper company will receive $37 million after overseeing […]

The Guardian makes its news schedule public

Journalism blog 10,000 Words posted today about how The Guardian will began sharing parts of its story schedule publicly, to get pre-publication feedback and guidance from its audience. I like this idea, and have for as long as I’ve worked online. However, implementing something like this raises some practical considerations. They have nothing to do […]

Jury duty: What happens when you’re summoned to the Supreme Court of British Columbia

For someone who deals with crime news daily, I’ve spent very little time in a courtroom. I’ve received plenty of copy from the courthouse, but have never written any myself. I’ve always wanted to see a trial from the inside by serving on a jury, but when I got my call recently, I had to […]

Links I liked this week, Vol. 4

Every weekend I round up a few links that caught my interest as they drifted past during the previous week. Many are related to digital journalism and writing, but they may also touch on my other interests like sports, music or life in Vancouver. Here’s the fourth installment: A great, detailed post from Howard Owens […]